Some pretty awesome guesses guys! Really close to the actuals in terms of weight. Here're the actual numbers! Christopher K and Getin were closest I'd say!
Fish #1 Largemouth, just about 19.5" (can't tell EXACTLY) and a weight of about 4.4 lbs:
Fish #2 Smallmouth, about 18.5" and a weight of about 3.28 lbs if I recall correctly