Hey, A group (6) of us stayed at the West Arm Lodge last September to check it out. Our annual June fishing trip group (11) were looking for a new lodge for our June fishing trip. We arrived on a Thursday and left on the Monday (4 nights). The cottages are good, clean and right next to the water. The boats are well maintained 16' with 15hp motors - no live wells or fish finders. Frank and Cathy (owners) were great and very helpful.
We caught several large / small mouth, some small pike, some perch and 1 large Musky. Many of the large mouth bass we caught were over 3lbs with 1 weighing in just under 5lbs. The small mouths were a good size as well. The pike were all small, but not to say that they aren't there - we just didn't latch on to any. We did not catch any walleye, but we were not really targeting them. Anyway, we had a nice fish fry of bass and perch in front of our cottage next to the water. Add a couple of cold ones and it doesn't get any better.
As a result of this fall trip we are already booked for the opening season of Bass this June and again in September!
Hope this helps. Good luck!